Elliott Bay Pizza & Pub

Elliot Bay Pizza and Pub in Mill Creek is a gem! Their pizza is hands down the best in the area—perfectly crisp crust, generous toppings, and that ideal balance of flavors that keeps you coming back for more. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, making it a great spot for family dinners or meeting up with friends. Their beer selection is solid, with plenty of local brews on tap to pair with your meal. The service is always friendly and attentive, even during busy hours. If you’re in the Mill Creek area and craving pizza, this is the place to go! Highly recommend.

Stopped in because I saw other reviews about Detroit style pizza. As a Michigander I know a thing or two about Detroit style pizza and theirs is a far cry from the real deal. Dough was tasty but not quite thick enough to be Detroit style. Meatballs were fantastic - loved the rosemary marinara sauce. Great selection of beer and cider on tap. I was unimpressed by the bartender - he seemed more focused on his budding relationship than taking care of customers.

Omg so freaking good I got the Detroit style with pepperoni and mushrooms and had a Brazilian limeade cider while i waited and it was super delicious but the pizza oh hell yeah i will most definitely be back. Also the wait staff was awesome everything about this place was top notch 20 different beers on tap. Y'all should for sure check em out if ya get a chance

I am from Michigan and lived in Detroit for years, during which time I had Buddy’s pizza regularly. Buddy’s I believe, is where Detroit style pizza originated. Tonight at Elliot Bay Pizza my husband and I had Detroit style with spicy sausage, meatballs, fresh mushrooms and black olives. It was fabulous. The mushrooms were fresh, the meatballs chunky, and the sausage was sliced like pepperoni. The cheese was melty and plentiful. The crust was not as oily as Buddy’s which was okay with us. One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long, long time. The beer and wine and service were equally good

Love the sandwiches here, but y’all need to cook your pizza thoroughly, very doughy

Looooooong time favorite for delicious pizzas, subs & craft beers! We have unfortunately noticed a steady decline in service and attention to beer upkeep over the last several visits and our last visit was so unusually unpleasant that I'm not sure we will be coming back...but we always do. I am all for giving second (and even third) chances, but this would be their fourth or fifth chance, haha. What's happening? Frustrating would be an understatement. We drive all the way up from Seattle and all we want to do is give you our hard earned money and eat your delicious food, so please act like you appreciate our presence. Ugh, you've got us addicted EBP! We'll probably be back. YUM!